Friday, November 20, 2026

Foucault’s Critique of Psychiatry

 


 

 Dr Ruwan M Jayatunge M.D. PhD 

In his 1961 book, “Madness and Civilization,” Michel Foucault argued that psychiatry is not an objective, neutral science, but a tool of social control. He stated that society uses definitions of "madness" and "reason" to police behavior, enforce conformity, and silence people who disrupt social order. He further stated that rather than simply discovering natural illnesses inside the brain, society constructs the boundary between "reason" and "madness" to manage anyone who threatens economic productivity, social order, or accepted morality.

Foucault regarded madness and modern concepts of mental illness as social constructs because he saw them as products of shifting historical norms, power dynamics, and social institutions rather than purely objective, timeless medical facts. Foucault traces how Western society created a sharp divide between rationality and irrationality—a divide that was not always fixed.

According to Foucault, society defines what counts as normal and rational by marking certain behaviours or people as irrational and deviant, often medicalizing social deviance. Foucault argued that how societies understand and respond to "madness" changes across eras.

Foucault stated that psychiatric knowledge and medical categories do not simply discover neutral truths; they help define what counts as "normal" and "abnormal". Labelling behaviour as pathology gives institutions and authorities power to regulate, classify, and manage people who deviate from social expectations.

Foucault pointed out that modern medicalized psychiatry turned madness into an object of expert diagnosis while marginalizing the direct voice and lived experience of the person labelled "mad."

Foucault rejected the idea that modern psychiatry represents an inevitable, purely scientific march of human progress, arguing instead that its concepts are tied to specific cultural and political arrangements. 

 

Lobotomies in America: A Failed Psychiatric Miracle

Between the late 1930s and the 1950s, tens of thousands of psychiatric patients in the United States underwent lobotomies, a controversial psychosurgical procedure aimed at severing nerve pathways in the brain's prefrontal cortex to treat severe mental illnesses like schizophrenia, depression, and obsessive-compulsive disorder.

Introduced by Portuguese neurologist António Egas Moniz and aggressively popularized in America by physician Walter Freeman—who developed the rapid "transorbital" or ice-pick lobotomy—the procedure was widely hailed as a miracle cure to empty overcrowded state mental asylums.

Despite its widespread adoption, the lobotomy proved largely irrelevant as a true medical cure because it did not treat the underlying psychiatric disorders, instead masking symptoms by destroying higher cognitive functions. Its harmful effects were devastating and irreversible, frequently leaving patients with severe personality changes, emotional blunting, intellectual impairment, incontinence, seizures, vegetative states, or death—notably seen in high-profile cases like Rosemary Kennedy.

Lobotomy stands as one of the darkest chapters in modern medical history—a scientifically invalidated, barbaric practice driven by institutional desperation rather than genuine patient welfare. Foucault’s ideas strongly condemn practices like psychosurgery as extreme tools of institutional control and bodily subjugation.

  

Sluggish Schizophrenia As a Political Weapon

Sluggish schizophrenia was a discredited Soviet psychiatric diagnosis used to suppress political dissent. Developed in the 1960s by psychiatrist Andrei Snezhnevsky, it relied on vague criteria such as “anti-Soviet thinking,” “overvalued ideas,” and “delusions of reformism.”

Soviet authorities sometimes portrayed dissatisfaction with a system that provided education, employment, and subsidized housing as evidence of mental illness. In practice, critics of the Communist Party and human-rights activists could be labelled mentally ill and confined indefinitely in psychiatric hospitals. The diagnosis was not accepted by the World Health Organization or the international medical community.

Human-rights activist Vladimir Bukovsky, arrested in 1963 for possessing banned literature, was diagnosed with the condition. After years in psychiatric prisons, he smuggled more than 150 pages of official psychiatric evaluations to Western specialists in 1971, helping expose the use of forced treatment against dissidents. Major General Pyotr Grigorenko was another prominent political dissident confined in Soviet psychiatric hospitals.

Sluggish schizophrenia became a textbook real-world example of Michel Foucault’s warning about power/knowledge—showing how state authorities can define political nonconformity as "madness" to strip citizens of their rights and credibility under the guise of medical care. 

 

Rosenhan Experiment

In 1973, Stanford University psychologist David Rosenhan published a landmark study in the journal Science titled "On Being Sane in Insane Places," which set out to test whether psychiatric hospital staff could reliably tell the difference between sane individuals and genuinely mentally ill patients.

Rosenhan designed a two-part field experiment. In the first phase, Rosenhan and seven mentally healthy volunteers—comprising graduate students, a psychologist, a pediatrician, a painter, and a housewife—acted as "pseudopatients" and sought admission to 12 different psychiatric hospitals across five U.S. states.

Each participant called for an appointment and reported a single fabricated symptom: hearing an unfamiliar, same-sex voice saying the words "empty," "hollow," or "thud." Aside from using fake names and occupations and claiming this isolated audio hallucination, every volunteer gave completely truthful accounts of their life histories, relationships, and emotional states.

Despite displaying no other signs of illness, all eight were admitted—seven diagnosed with schizophrenia and one with manic-depressive psychosis. Once inside the psychiatric wards, the pseudopatients immediately stopped simulating any symptoms, behaved completely normally, and informed the staff that they felt fine and no longer heard voices. They cooperated with ward routines, openly took written notes about hospital life, and secretly flushed their prescribed antipsychotic medications down the toilet. Despite their normal behavior, the medical staff never detected that any of the eight were faking, even though many actual patients on the wards quickly suspected they were undercover journalists or professors.

Instead, nurses and doctors interpreted ordinary actions through the lens of their diagnosis, recording their note-taking in medical charts as "writing behavior" and treating it as a symptom of paranoia. The pseudopatients were kept hospitalized for anywhere from 7 to 52 days, averaging 19 days, and were only discharged after agreeing with the doctors that they were mentally ill and accepting release with a diagnosis of schizophrenia "in remission"—a label that implied the illness had merely subsided rather than never existed.

In the second phase of the study, a skeptical research and teaching hospital challenged Rosenhan to send pseudopatients to their facility over a three-month period, boasting that their staff would easily catch the impostors. Rosenhan agreed to the test, and hospital staff subsequently rated every incoming patient on a ten-point scale, flagging 41 out of 193 new patients as suspected fakes—even though Rosenhan had secretly sent zero pseudopatients during that entire period.

David Rosenhan concluded that psychiatric diagnoses are not reliable, objective medical assessments, because hospital staff cannot distinguish the sane from the insane once a diagnostic label is applied. David Rosenhan’s experiment served as real-world empirical proof that reinforced Foucault’s arguments during his 1970s lectures on psychiatric power.

  

The Case of P.P. Jamis

The case of P.P. Jamis illustrates how a person can remain confined in an institution despite no longer needing treatment. After committing an offence in 1958, Jamis was sent to Angoda Mental Hospital in Sri Lanka for evaluation. A judge found him mentally ill and unfit to stand trial, and ordered his detention in the hospital’s forensic unit.

Although doctors later treated him successfully and deemed him fit, he remained there for 50 years, from age 34 to 84. The hospital could not release him directly into the community and could only transfer him to prison authorities, who in turn required a court order. Because his case file had been lost, the courts never summoned him.

Following intervention by activists, Jamis was released on bail in 2008. His case exposed a profound failure of coordination and legal oversight among the judiciary, prison system, and mental health authorities. The case of P.P. Jamis reveals that the greatest harm surrounding mental illness often comes not from the illness itself, but from how legal and medical institutions treat people once they are labelled.

P.P. Jamis’s story serves as a stark, real-world validation of Michel Foucault’s core claims about how psychiatric and legal institutions exercise power—showing how an asylum can strip an individual of legal rights and human agency indefinitely, even after they are cured.

  

Medicalizing Childhood Behavior

The debate over the diagnosis of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and the prescribing of stimulant medications such as Ritalin (methylphenidate) in North America concerns whether increasing diagnosis rates reflect improved clinical recognition or the medicalization of ordinary childhood behaviour and responses to academic pressure.

Behaviours associated with ADHD can also arise in other circumstances: children exposed to severe stress or domestic violence, for example, may show similar symptoms, while anxiety and vitamin B deficiencies may also contribute to attention and behaviour difficulties. These possibilities underscore the importance of careful assessment before diagnosis or treatment.

Over-diagnosis and inappropriate prescribing may expose children to medication risks and affect their developing brain chemistry, making it essential to consider alternative explanations and individual circumstances.


Professor Hans Eysenck's Claim

Professor Hans Eysenck argued that psychological abnormality should not be treated as a distinct category of disease. Instead, he proposed that it represents an extreme position on continuous, measurable personality dimensions that are present in everyone. Using mathematical factor analysis, Eysenck developed the Continuity Hypothesis, which challenges the idea that normality and abnormality are entirely separate states. Under this view, mental disorders reflect unusually pronounced statistical variations in ordinary personality traits.

  

The Sane Society and the Mentally Ill

The psychologist Erich Fromm proposed that not just individuals but entire societies “may be lacking in sanity.” Eric Fromm further says that “yet many psychiatrists and psychologists refuse to entertain the idea that society as a whole may be lacking in sanity. They hold that the problem of mental health in a society is only that of the number of” unadjusted’ individuals and not of a possible un-adjustment of the culture itself.


Special Thanks to

Dr. Beryl Logan -York University – Department of Philosophy

Dr. Neil J Fernando – Consultant psychiatrist – Sri Lanka

Dr. Peter Zelina – Psychiatrist -Mackenzie Richmond Hill Hospital Canada 




Thursday, November 19, 2026

The Anatomy of a Descent: Exploring Michael Corleone's Psychological Transformation.

 



 

 Dr Ruwan M Jayatunge 

I am pleased to present a brief analysis of the fictional character Michael Corleone and his psychological profile to the psychology undergraduates at York University. I would like to express my gratitude to Professor Richard N. Lalonde for his invaluable insights.

Michael Corleone, a creation of the great novelist Mario Puzo, was later brought to life on screen by director Francis Ford Coppola. Al Pacino's portrayal of Michael Corleone is particularly remarkable, as he masterfully captures the character's profound transformation throughout the narrative.

Michael Corleone was a naive college boy who had no desire to become involved in the family's mafia activities. He was aware of the family's operations in America but consciously sought to distance himself from that criminal world.

His enlistment in the Marines during World War II was motivated by a desire to bring honor and legitimacy to the Corleone name. This decision, however, disappointed his father, Vito, who had the influence to exempt him from the draft, and angered his older brother, Sonny. Even Tom Hagen, his stepbrother, noted that their father had envisioned a different path for Michael. Ultimately, Michael's choice to serve was driven by a quest for recognition and identity for the family.

After the war, Michel returns home, celebrated as a hero, bringing a sense of pride to his family's tarnished reputation. During his sister's wedding, he exposed dark secrets about his family to his girlfriend Kate and expressed his desire to distance himself from them. However, the situation takes a dramatic turn when an assassination attempt on his father by Virgil Solonso alters Michel's perspective and circumstances.

With this incident, Michael's life took a significant turn, revealing the depths of his character. As an introvert, he rarely displays his emotions, and instances of him losing control are few and far between. One notable occasion occurred when Kate confronted him about Connie’s claim that he had murdered her husband, prompting a fierce response from Michael as he asserted, "Don't question my business," with palpable anger.

Another critical moment arose when Kate disclosed the truth about their third child; rather than a miscarriage, it was a voluntary abortion, which sent Michael into a rage, culminating in a violent slap. The final incident involved Joey Sasa's attempt on Michael's life, which left him shaken. After narrowly escaping, he faced further agitation when Sonny's illegitimate son, Vincent Mancini, insisted on killing Sasa, triggering a hyperglycemic attack due to his diabetes condition.

In contrast to Michel, his older brother Sunny exhibited a fiery temperament and often acted impulsively, lacking rational thought in his decisions. Sonny Corleone's fiery temperament ultimately proved detrimental to his role as a Don. Indeed, he was a bad Don. His inability to mask his emotions, particularly his anger and desire for vengeance, marked his downfall. In contrast, his brother Michael was more reserved, rarely displaying negative feelings. As a result of Michael’s emotionless face, his enemies could not predict his next move.

During a crucial meeting with Virgil Sollozzo, known as the Turk, Sonny made a critical mistake by interrupting his father. Sollozzo sought to establish a narcotics operation in New York, relying on Vito Corleone's protection, and was supported by Philip Tattaglia. Despite Sollozzo's guarantee for the million-dollar investment, Vito refused to engage in the drug trade. Sonny's interruption led Sollozzo to mistakenly believe that he had Sonny's approval for the deal, which ultimately motivated Sollozzo to target Vito. This miscalculation marked a pivotal moment in the unfolding conflict, as Sollozzo decided to eliminate Vito Corleone.

Michael Corleone's world fell apart following the assassination attempt on his father. Aware that Solonso was behind the attack, Michael recognized the backing of the corrupt police chief, Maculsky, which made the situation even more perilous. Michel knew that Solonso was going to get his father. Determined to save his father’s life, Michael devised a plan to orchestrate a meeting with both Solonso and Maculsky, intending to eliminate them and ensure his father’s safety and reclaim his family's power. By doing this, he was compelled to sacrifice his peaceful civilian life and his girlfriend, Kate. However, he did it willfully.

Michael attended a meeting with Solonso and Makulsky, during which he displayed a stoic demeanour, primarily listening to Solonso. After a brief moment, he excused himself, heading to the men's loo where he retrieved a concealed firearm. In a shocking turn of events, he then returned and fatally shot both Solonso and Makulsky.

After the double murder, Michel was forced to escape to Sicily, where he found refuge with Don Thomasino, an old associate of Vito Corleone. During his time in exile, he encountered a lovely village girl named Apollonia and eventually married her.

The reasons behind Michel's betrayal of Kate and his subsequent marriage to Apollonia warrant further examination. Feeling isolated, Michel sought solace in a close relationship, uncertain when he would return to the United States or what his future with Kate would hold. During his time in Sicily, he became increasingly interested in exploring his family roots. He viewed Apollonia as a pure figure- a virgin from the village of Corleone, which likely influenced his decision. However, his newfound happiness was soon overshadowed by tragedy.

Carlo Rizzi, Michel's brother-in-law, was abusive to his wife, Connie. By marrying Connie, Carlo Rizzi understood that he was entering the world of organized crime. However, he was not assigned any significant role within the family; instead, he received only a living allowance. This situation led to feelings of disappointment, frustration, and anger, which Carlo ultimately directed towards his wife. When Sonny discovered Carlo's violent behaviour, he confronted him and brutally attacked him in public. Enraged by the humiliation, Carlo conspired with Tataglia and mafia boss Emilio Barzini to orchestrate an ambush against Sonny, which ultimately led to Sonny's death. Their scheme extended to Michel as well; they bribed his bodyguard, Fabrizio, and planted a bomb in Michel's car. Although Michel narrowly escaped the assassination attempt, his newlywed wife, Apolina, tragically lost her life in the explosion.

Following the tragic loss of his son Sonny, Vito Corleone, who is recovering from gunshot wounds, convened a meeting with the leaders of the five families. His primary objective was to propose a peace agreement with Philip Tattaglia, seeking safe passage for his son Michael. During the meeting, Vito assured the attendees that he would uphold the terms of the peace deal, emphasizing his commitment to maintaining stability among the families.

This meeting marks Michael's return to America, where he reunites with his father. Upon his arrival, he seeks out his former girlfriend, Kate, and proposes marriage, assuring her that he will legitimize their family within five years. Shortly thereafter, Vito Corleone retires, and Michel ascends to the role of the new Boss. He now faces a looming threat from Barzini.

Following the death of the Godfather, Sal Tessio, one of the Caporegimes, made a significant shift by aligning himself with Emilio Barzini, believing that the Corleone family was declining under Michael's leadership. Tessio viewed Michael as an inexperienced youth, while Vito Corleone, with his seasoned insight, recognized Barzini's intent to eliminate the Corleone family. Barzini took advantage of the family's internal conflicts, reaching out to Carlo, Michael's brother-in-law, to orchestrate Sonny's assassination. His next target was Michael, whom he arranged to meet through Tessio in Brooklyn, planning to ambush him. However, Vito Corleone warned Michael of the looming danger, allowing him to prepare for a counterattack against Barzini and the other crime family heads. This confrontation unfolded on the day of Connie's child's baptism, during which Michael, serving as the godfather, executed the planned hits while in the church.

The baptism scene has numerous contradictions.  Michael Corleone, in the church, proclaims that he renounces Satan and embraces Christ. While he is undergoing the baptismal ritual, his henchmen gun down his enemies. This shows a pure Machiavellian approach to power.

Vito Corleone had once relied on the notorious Luca Brasi, a fearsome enforcer, but Michael chose Al Neri, a former police officer, as his primary hitman, recognizing Neri's superior capabilities. Here I want to say a few words about Luca Brasi, Here I have a question: Luca Brasi was a merciless assassin, infamous for his brutal actions, including the chilling act of throwing his firstborn into a furnace. This raises questions about Vito Corleone's decision to rely on such a violent psychopath.

After the baptism, Michael instructed Carlo to go to a safe house and wait for him. Confused and anxious, Carlo was frantically making calls. Then Michael arrived with shocking news: He says Barzini is dead, so is Philip Tattaglia, Moe Greene, Cuneo, and Stracci. This revelation heightened Carlo's fear, as Michael employed psychological tactics to extract a confession from him. Michel put Carlo at ease, telling him that he would not kill Carlo and make his sister a widow. Then Carlo opened up and said that he was collaborating with Barzini in Sonny's murder. Michael handed Carlo an airline ticket and instructed him to head to the car. As soon as he sits in the front passenger seat, he is garroted by Peter Clemenza. That ended the fate of Carlo, Michael's brother-in-law.

Sal Tassio, a long-time associate of Vito Calione and one of the trusted Capros, faced a similar fate. He plotted to betray Michael by orchestrating a fake meeting with Barzini in Brooklyn, where they intended to eliminate him. Although Tessio was intelligent, he misjudged Michael's insight and abilities. According to the novel, Sal was taken to an abandoned gas station in Staten Island, where he was shot and his body disposed of.

A pivotal event unfolded before Vito Corleone's death, centred around Michael's ambition to acquire hotels in Las Vegas. He approached Moe Greene with a proposal, which provoked Green's fury, as he perceived the Corleone family's growing ineptitude. In a heated exchange, Green insulted Michael and threatened to ally himself with Barzini. Remember what he said to Michael: "I'm Moe Greene! I made my bones when you were going out with cheerleaders!".

Despite the provocation, Michael maintained his self-possession, calmly suggesting that Green consider a price for the hotel. The situation escalated when Michael's older brother, Fredo, sided with Green, prompting Michael to caution him against taking any stance that could jeopardize the family. Remember what Michael said to his brother? "Fredo, you're my older brother, and I love you. But don't ever take sides with anyone against the Family again. Ever."

This confrontation ultimately sealed Green's fate, as Michael was determined to eliminate him.

In The Godfather Part One, Michael Corleone undergoes a profound transformation, evolving from a naive college boy into a ruthless crime lord. His journey culminates in the chilling act of murdering his own brother-in-law, leaving his sister a widow, and later, he even takes the life of his elder brother, Fredo. This shift in character is striking, especially when compared to Vito Corleone, who, despite his formidable power, never crossed certain moral boundaries. Vito's actions were limited to eliminating two significant threats: Don Fanucci, the Black Hand mafia boss, and Don Ciccio, the local Mafia chieftain in Corleone, Sicily, who was responsible for the deaths of his parents and two brothers.

After eliminating the leaders of the five families and neutralizing potential threats, Michael decides to leave New York for Nevada. Although he has resolved all family matters by dispatching his rivals, remaining in New York would have made him vulnerable to retaliation from their successors.

By relocating his operations to Nevada, he aims to shift the family's focus toward legitimate business ventures and escape the street violence of New York. This strategic move reflects his intention to seek legitimacy for the family. Nevertheless, Michael does not completely sever ties with New York; he entrusts the management of traditional mafia activities to reliable capos like Clemenza and, later, Frank Pentangeli. 

In God father part 2, we meet another character: Hyman Roth. Micheal’s father did business with Hyman Roth, but never trusted him. Roth is a shrewd and aging Jewish mobster who orchestrates a failed assassination attempt on Michael and his wife, Kay, at their Lake Tahoe residence, sending gunmen to fire indiscriminately into their bedroom. While the couple escapes unharmed, the incident marks a significant turning point for Kay, who begins to suspect the Corleone family's ambitions toward legitimacy.

In Cuba, Roth attempts to manipulate Michael into investing $2 million in a business venture, which he intends to seize after orchestrating Michael's assassination through military means. Michael, being highly observant, notices the rising guerrilla activities in Cuba and is reluctant to jeopardize his investments.

Motivated by a desire for revenge for Michael's killing of Moe Greene, Roth seeks to eliminate him to solidify his control over gambling operations in both Nevada and Cuba, recognizing Greene's pivotal role in transforming Las Vegas into a bustling metropolis.

Another crucial factor was that Frank Pentangeli turned against Michael Corleone because he was tricked into believing Michael had ordered his assassination. In reality, the betrayal was a "masterstroke" by Hyman Roth to eliminate Michael by using the government’s legal system.

The Senate hearing was a complex trap designed to dismantle Michael Corleone’s criminal empire from the outside while he was being attacked from the inside. The hearings were masterminded by Hyman Roth. While the public face of the investigation was a U.S. Senate subcommittee, Roth manipulated the proceedings through several channels. Roth used his high-level political connections to arrange for the investigation into the Corleone family.

Believing Michael was his enemy, a vengeful Frank Pentangeli sought protection from the FBI. Michael Corleone escaped the Senate proceedings through a combination of psychological warfare, blackmail, and a masterstroke of intimidation that dismantled the government's star witness. The appearance of Frank's brother Vincenzo Pentangeli was the turning point that destroyed the government's case against Michael Corleone. His presence acted as a powerful silent message that operated on two levels: family honor and indirect threat.

Michel dispatched his advisor, Tom Hegan, to the FBI barracks to deliver a message to Frank Pentangeli. In ancient Rome, a traitor would often take their own life to restore their honor and protect their family after committing treason. Understanding the gravity of Michael's message, Pentangali chose to follow this tradition; once Tom departed, he took his own life by cutting his veins.

Although Michel won the Senate hearing it affected his personal life. His marriage fell apart. Michael lost Kay because she realized his promise to make the family business "completely legitimate" was a lie. Over time, his increasing ruthlessness and the violence that invaded their home convinced her that there was no hope for a normal life together.

After the Cuban Revolution, Roth attempted to find asylum in Israel under the Law of Return. However, the Israeli High Court rejected his request due to his criminal background, forcing him to return to the United States. Upon his arrival at Miami International Airport, Roth was surrounded by federal agents, police, and reporters. Michael Corleone orchestrated a public, almost suicidal assassination to ensure Roth did not survive to testify or continue his schemes.

Michael’s brother Fredo Corleone's betrayal was rooted in his deep-seated jealousy and resentment at being "passed over" by Michael to lead the family. Fredo’s primary driver is a profound inferiority complex. Being the middle brother—sandwiched between the fiery, dominant Sonny and the brilliant, cold Michael—he felt constantly "stepped over." He spent his entire life trying to prove he was "smart" and capable, but his efforts usually resulted in making him look more imprudent.

Fredo was approached in Beverly Hills by Johnny Ola, an associate of Hyman Roth.  Ola and Roth manipulated Fredo's fragile ego by treating him with the respect he felt he lacked from his own family. Michael Corleone decided to kill Fredo because he viewed his brother as an irrevocable security threat and a "loose end" that could destroy the family.

Tom Hagen was likely aware of Fredo's impending assassination, as he seemed to understand Michael's intentions. Furthermore, even Connie, Fredo's sister, later recognized that Fredo's death was deemed necessary for the family's welfare. However, as time passed, Michael expressed remorse over his actions, reflecting on the gravity of killing his own brother.

In the third episode, Michael attempts to legitimize his business operations, receiving accolades from the Vatican while striving for a more lawful enterprise. Despite his efforts, he is continually beset by adversaries. As he seeks to reconnect with his family and invest in legitimate ventures, he finds himself trapped in violence due to the ambitions of a new generation. Michael proposes a substantial amount of money to the Vatican Bank in exchange for control of Immobiliare, facing resistance from corrupt officials and rival mafia leaders.

Meanwhile, his son Anthony rejects the family legacy to pursue a career in opera, while his daughter Mary becomes involved in a forbidden romance with her cousin Vincent. During Anthony's opera inauguration in Sicily, a series of violent events unfolds, culminating in the tragic death of Mary, who is mistakenly shot by an assassin targeting Michael.  The loss of his daughter left Michel fully broken, as she was the person he cherished most, and he was never able to heal from that profound grief.

The film concludes years later with a frail and isolated Michael, who dies of a heart attack in a Sicilian garden, burdened by the memories of the women he lost, ultimately finding no peace in his life and passing away as a broken man.

Who was Michel, and what was his legacy?

Michael Corleone undergoes a tragic metamorphosis from an idealistic war hero to a cold, calculating mafia leader, marked by his isolation and ruthlessness. While he inherits his father Vito's intelligence and craftiness, he lacks the warmth that characterized Vito's leadership, opting instead to govern through fear and strategic manipulation.

Michael's personality is defined by his exceptional ability to plan meticulously and make precise decisions, often scrutinizing those around him for signs of betrayal. Unlike his impulsive brother Sonny, Michael exhibits remarkable self-control, which eventually evolves into a complete emotional detachment, enabling him to make heart-wrenching decisions, such as ordering the death of his own brother, Fredo, without a trace of remorse.

He perceives himself as a "sacrificial hero," burdened by the responsibility to protect a family that increasingly resents him, driven by an obsession to legitimize their name that ultimately consumes him. As a naturally introverted and aloof figure, Michael navigates the treacherous landscape of organized crime with a blend of charm and intimidation, grappling with his moral dilemmas while embracing the darker facets of power and loyalty.

He oscillates between vulnerability and dominance, ultimately becoming a formidable leader who prioritizes the family's legacy above all else. His evolution from an outsider to the head of the Corleone family underscores the themes of power, loyalty, and the cost of ambition, making him one of the most powerful Dons.

Michael Corleone embodies a complex personality characterized by a chilling efficiency and a deepening emotional detachment. He is a master strategist who not only reacts to threats but also foresees them long before they materialize. His approach to challenges is methodical and calculated, treating each encounter as a strategic game of chess. This is exemplified by his composed demeanor during high-stakes situations, such as when he stood vigil outside the hospital to safeguard his father from assassins.

Michael possesses an unsettling ability to compartmentalize his life, impeccably separating his ruthless business dealings from his personal relationships. He can participate in a family baptism while simultaneously orchestrating the execution of his adversaries, a mental separation that allows him to commit heinous acts without immediate remorse, though it ultimately leads to his moral decay. Unlike his father, Vito Corleone, who valued loyalty and reason, Michael operates with a blunt utilitarian mindset. He prioritizes the survival of the Corleone legacy over individual lives, willing to eliminate even his own brother, Fredo, if deemed a threat to the family's interests.

As the narrative unfolds, Michael's transformation from a protective leader to a solitary tyrant becomes evident. His growing paranoia and inability to trust others foster a profound loneliness, stripping away the idealism he once held as a war hero who sought to distance himself from the Mafia. Ultimately, his greatest flaw lies in his self-deception; he convinces himself that his violent actions are for the sake of his family, using their protection as a moral shield. Ironically, it is this very violence, deceit, and secrecy that alienate his wife and children, driving a wedge between him and the loved ones he claims to protect.

The central message of The Godfather saga is that the pursuit of power at the expense of family eventually destroys the very family it was meant to protect. The trilogy suggests that the "American Dream" is often built on crime and that there is no real difference between a mafia Don and a corrupt politician or business mogul. Michael discovers that the "legitimate" world is just as treacherous as the underworld.

Vito Corleone died in a garden playing with his grandson, surrounded by love. In contrast, Michael dies alone in a chair. The saga’s ultimate lesson is that ruling through fear (as Michael did) leads to a solitary death, whereas ruling through respect and community (as Vito did) creates a lasting legacy.

 

 

 

 

 

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Searching for Positive Buddhism

 


 

 Dr. Ruwan M. Jayatunge, M.D. PhD 

Contemporary Buddhism is mixed with Hindu, Jain, and Brahmanical ideas, and its true philosophy is contaminated. Contemporary Buddhism provides a wrong life philosophy, and it can be detrimental to the followers. Present-day Buddhism is often criticized as having pessimistic or life-negating tendencies and for demotivating people.

Contemporary interpretations of Buddhism may contribute to disengagement from worldly life, expressed through diminished enthusiasm, disenchantment, restlessness, reduced motivation and courage, weakened self-confidence and self-esteem, feelings of guilt, and limited attention to building stable household lives. These attitudes may also discourage individuals from pursuing economic advancement and innovation, thereby hindering wealth creation and contributing to persistent poverty in Buddhist communities.

Today, many Buddhist monks highlight that life is full of suffering; life is despair, devoid of happiness. This life-negating philosophy negatively reinforces Buddhist masses. This wrong message has caused Buddhists not to thrive in their worldly lives, diminished their motivation and put them in limbo.

They have a pessimistic view of mundane life.  Moreover, the doctrine labels natural human desires as mental defilements and unwholesome deeds and creates deep guilt in people. This erroneous life philosophy has created a dilemma, and following these mixed messages, Buddhists have become less progressive; they are discouraged from pursuing worldly goals, have become less thriving, and live with a cynical outlook on life. This negative life philosophy hinders personal and social progress.

Buddhism begins with the recognition that existence involves dissatisfaction, a premise that is sometimes viewed as unduly pessimistic. Its emphasis on craving as a source of suffering may also be interpreted as overlooking the biological and developmental origins of human desire. When ordinary desires emerge through natural, age-related hormonal and developmental processes, describing them as sinful or defiled can seem to conflict with human biology. From this perspective, natural passions, ambitions, and worldly pleasures may be treated as afflictions rather than normal aspects of human life. Such an interpretation can lead followers to experience considerable guilt and shame about desires that arise naturally.

Nietzsche viewed Buddhism as a "life-negating" and nihilistic philosophy. According to Nietzsche, Buddhism says "no" to earthly life. Such a philosophy leads people to believe that life is irredeemably bad, with no escape.  Hegel criticized Buddhism primarily as a "religion of nothingness" that encourages passive withdrawal from the world.

Life indeed involves birth, aging, sickness, death, and dissatisfaction.  The idea that life involves unavoidable suffering is a central theme across major world philosophies, religions, and evolutionary psychology. Some believe that dissatisfaction, loss, and pain are built-in parts of human existence.

Arthur Schopenhauer and Viktor Frankl viewed suffering as an inherent condition of consciousness and freedom. From a biological standpoint, humans are wired to pay far more attention to threats, losses, and pain than to positive experiences. The human mind naturally fixates on threats and past regrets. This survival instinct makes painful moments feel much larger and longer than peaceful ones.

Human existence is a constant mix of joy, meaning, beauty, and pain. Life holds deep joy alongside its challenges. Focusing entirely on suffering misses the immense beauty, connection, and happiness that make life worth living. Ancient Stoic philosophers believed that external events themselves do not cause suffering; rather, our judgments about those events do.

Buddha acknowledged everyday joys, friendships, and pleasant moments (Cooper, 2021). True Buddhism is realistic rather than pessimistic because it offers a path to end suffering (Rahula, 1974). Authentic Buddhist teaching does not portray life as inherently unhappy or miserable. Instead, it encourages an objective understanding of human experience, recognizing both life’s meaningful joys and its unavoidable difficulties (Jayatunge, 2008). The Buddha acknowledged the happiness found in family life, loving friendships, ethical prosperity, good health, and acts of generosity. He taught that joy and suffering are both part of life, while emphasizing the value of living in the present moment and practicing mindfulness. By attending carefully to the present moment, people can meet life’s challenges with greater clarity and reduce the stress and anxiety that often arise from dwelling on the past or worrying about the future.

The Dhamma preached by the Buddha was transmitted through oral tradition for thousands of years. During this period, numerous social upheavals occurred in Buddhist societies such as India and Sri Lanka. Consequently, there was significant potential for a doctrine passed down orally to become distorted. Furthermore, in later periods, Hindu and Jain concepts, as well as the ideas and interpretations of Indian Brahmins, were absorbed into Buddhism. As a result, instead of true Buddhism, what exists today is a doctrine blended with various erroneous views. Therefore, it is essential to uncover the authentic words of the Buddha and move toward a true interpretation of life."

The Buddha did not teach that life is inherently defined by darkness and suffering. Rather, the claim that existence is wholly miserable or a negative snare from which one must escape may reflect later interpretations shaped by Jain, Hindu, and Brahmanical ideas that became interwoven with Buddhist thought. For this reason, such teachings should be approached critically, with careful discernment and a sincere effort to distinguish later influences from the Buddha’s original teachings.



References

Cooper, D. E. (2021). Buddhism as pessimism. Journal of World Philosophies, 6(2), 1–16. doi.org

Frankl, V. E. (2006). Man's search for meaning (I. Lasch, Trans.). Beacon Press. (Original work published 1946)

Hegel, G. W. F. (1987). Lectures on the philosophy of religion: Vol. 2. Determinate religion (R. F. Brown, P. C. Hodgson, & J. M. Stewart, Trans.; P. C. Hodgson, Ed.). University of California Press. (Original work published 1832)

Jayatunge, R. M. (2008). Buddhism and psychology: Similarities and differences in Buddhism and Western psychology. Ahas Publishers.

Nietzsche, F. (1977). The Antichrist (W. Kaufmann, Trans.). In W. Kaufmann (Ed.), The portable Nietzsche (pp. 565–656). Penguin Books. (Original work published 1895)

Rahula, W. (1974). What the Buddha taught (2nd ed.). Grove Press.  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Friday, November 13, 2026

How Sri Lanka’s 1988–89 Uprising Created a Collective Trauma

 


 

 Dr Ruwan M Jayatunge, M.D. PhD 

The 1987–1989 (JVP) insurrection—widely remembered in Sri Lanka as the Era of Terror- was a brutal conflict between the JVP rebels and the Sri Lankan state. Historians and human rights organizations estimate that between 40,000 and 60,000 people were killed or forcibly disappeared across the southern, central, and western parts of the island, leaving a deep, lasting collective trauma.

The 1987–1989 uprising in Sri Lanka arose from authoritarian repression, youth unemployment, and Sinhalese nationalist opposition to the Indo-Lanka Accord. Although the 1987 agreement with India was the immediate catalyst, longstanding inequality and political exclusion had already created deep resentment.

After the anti-Tamil violence of Black July in 1983, the UNP government wrongly accused and banned the Janatha Vimukthi Peramuna (JVP) and other leftist parties. Driven underground, the JVP abandoned democratic politics and began preparing for armed struggle.

There were many push factors for the rebellion. The post-1977 shift to an open-market economy boosted urban business growth but widened economic disparities and weakened welfare protections rural families depended on. Meanwhile, free education produced many Sinhala-speaking rural graduates, but white-collar employment remained limited and disproportionately accessible to English-speaking urban elites.

Recruits often came from lower-middle-class rural families and marginalized castes in the southern provinces, where economic hardship, caste oppression, and exclusion from political power restricted prospects for social mobility.

Young people joined the 1987–1989 uprising in pursuit of social justice, patriotic purpose, and belonging in a system that excluded them. For many educated, rural, and lower-middle-class youths, the JVP offered an explanation for their hardships and a mission to transform the country. Its promise to challenge class and caste barriers resonated with rural and marginalized communities who felt dismissed by Colombo’s wealthy, English-speaking elite.

After Indian troops arrived in 1987, the JVP increasingly framed resistance as a patriotic struggle to defend Sri Lanka from foreign intervention and division. Anger over corruption and state repression also fueled support, while songs, pamphlets, and stories of figures such as Che Guevara and the 1971 insurgents celebrated discipline, sacrifice, and martyrdom as heroic acts.

The rebels acted with vengeance and assassinated thousands of people, many of them unnamed, including junior government officials, local Grama Niladharis (village grassroots government officers), teachers, school principals, clergy members, and people holding a range of political beliefs. They also targeted former members who had left the movement.

The killings were often exceptionally brutal, and victims were humiliated and tortured before being killed, sometimes in front of their families. The dead bodies were mutilated.

Through threats of death, the rebels imposed strict curfews and strikes that brought public transport, businesses, schools, and universities to a halt. Rebel leaders recruited schoolchildren as child soldiers, while members and supporters carried out murders, arson, and robberies. Some university students took part in violent operations, including shooting people, transporting explosives, and attacking army camps to seize weapons.

Government buildings, buses, and electrical transformers were destroyed. The rebels also established kangaroo courts, which sentenced and killed many people, including intellectuals such as Professor Chandratne Patuwathavithane and Professor Stanley Wijesundera. As violence and intimidation spread, ordinary life became increasingly paralyzed, and the public endured prolonged fear and terror.

In mid-1989, the JVP issued ultimatums threatening to execute security personnel’s family members unless the forces resigned, prompting a sharp escalation in state retaliation. The government granted security forces sweeping powers under Emergency Regulations and the Prevention of Terrorism Act, including detention without trial and the disposal of bodies without inquests.

Alongside the military and police, state-backed death squads—including the Black Cats, Yellow Cats, and Eagles of the Central Hills—operated with impunity. Security forces also used captured rebels, known as “Goni Billas,” to identify and arrest their former comrades. Detention and torture sites such as Eliyakanda, Yataro Cafeteria, and Batalanda became notorious, and many detainees died during interrogation.

The 1987–1989 JVP insurrection inflicted massive social and economic damage on Sri Lanka, bringing economic growth to a near standstill (dropping to 1.5% in 1987 and 2.3% in 1989).  During the 1987–1989 JVP insurrection, historians, human rights organizations, and international observers estimate that 40,000 to 60,000 people were killed or forcibly disappeared. Combined with the simultaneous civil war in the north and east, the southern uprising crippled public infrastructure, triggered widespread brain drain, and fractured rural communities for decades.

Sri Lanka’s 1987–1989 terror period inflicted profound collective trauma as extreme public violence invaded everyday life, turning neighbours against one another and denying families the right to mourn. Unlike a distant battlefield conflict, violence unfolded in homes, schools, and village streets, leaving psychological wounds that have endured across generations.

Both sides used brutality as psychological warfare: bodies burned on roadside tires, severed heads displayed near university campuses, and corpses carried down rivers became familiar sights. Social trust collapsed as neighbours informed on one another, sometimes to settle personal scores, while fear silenced communities, the media, and civic institutions. Commissions established in the 1990s documented more than 16,700 verified disappearances. Although some families later received compensation and death certificates, few perpetrators were prosecuted, leaving grief unresolved and deepening distrust in state institutions.

Rebels involved in the 1988–89 uprising committed grave atrocities, including killings, beheadings, mutilation of the dead, property destruction, looting, rape and, in some cases, betraying comrades during interrogation. Many survivors received no psychological support and now live in isolation, concealing their past. Some fled to Western countries and built comfortable lives under capitalist democracies. 

Former rebels who recount their past experiences often conceal or alter details, and some may even provide false accounts. As a result, only a small number share stories that appear to reflect what truly happened. Many former rebels continue to experience serious psychological challenges, including post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, substance dependence, and other mental health conditions. In some cases, these difficulties have not been identified or diagnosed, leaving individuals without access to appropriate treatment and support.

Members of the security forces who helped suppress the uprising experienced severe psychological trauma. Some participated in torturing or killing rebels, while others witnessed acts of brutality that exceeded the limits of ordinary human experience. Despite the psychological toll on those involved, the government had no system for providing mental health support to its own personnel. Many who took part in the crackdown suffered from moral injury, complex post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, addiction, and somatic symptoms. In some cases, the trauma became so overwhelming that individuals died by suicide.

The 1988–89 period was a collective trauma for Sri Lankans. The rebels, the security personnel who suppressed the uprising, and members of the general public who witnessed the violence were all psychologically affected by what they experienced. The suffering extended beyond those directly involved, profoundly affecting victims’ families and loved ones. Its impact has also endured across generations, while the psychological wounds left by this period remain largely untreated and unhealed.

Unfortunately, no meaningful reconciliation within the healing system followed the collective trauma of 1988–89. Those who took part in the uprising also failed to demonstrate a genuine commitment to ensuring that such events would not recur in our society. Instead, some have concealed or distorted the truth, while others have romanticized the uprising. These responses cannot heal the collective trauma that continues to affect Sri Lankan society. Honest acknowledgment of what happened, admission of mistakes, and concrete measures to prevent similar human-made disasters in the future are essential.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ සත්‍යට මුහුණ දීමට බියද ?



ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ යනු ශ්‍රී ලාංකික දේශපාලන ලේඛකයෙකු මෙන්ම 1988–1989 ජනතා විමුක්ති පෙරමුණේ  දේශපාලන ව්‍යාපාරයේ සක්‍රීය සාමාජිකයෙකු ලෙස කටයුතු කළ අයෙකි. ඔහු 88–89 කාලවකවානුවේදී ජනතා විමුක්ති පෙරමුණේ නායක රෝහණ විජේවීරට සමීපව කටයුතු අයෙකු ලෙස ප්‍රකටය. එම යුගයේ දේශපාලන අරගලය සහ අත්දැකීම් පිළිබඳව ඔහු විවිධ මාධ්‍ය සාකච්ඡා සහ ලිපි හරහා අදහස් දක්වයි. ඔහු සිය දේශපාලන ජීවිතයේ මතකයන් සහ 88–89 අරගලයේ ඉතිහාසය අළලා කෘති කිහිපයක් රචනා කර ඇත. ඒ අතර මතක ගිනි පුපුරු සහ නොනිමි අරගලයක මතක - පතී යන කෘති ප්‍රධාන තැනක් ගනී. ඔහු  සමාජ-දේශපාලන සටහන් සහ සිය අතීත මතකයන් නිරන්තරයෙන් පාඨකයන් සමඟ බෙදා ගනී.ඔහු  මිය ගිය සගයන් පිලිබඳව සඳහන් කිරීමේදී ඔවුන් උදාර අරමුණක් වෙනුවෙන් දිවි පිදූ බව නිතරම සඳහන් කරයි.

1988/89 යනු එවකට පැවති රජය සහ කැරළිකරුවන් ඉතා නිර්දය සහ තිරිසන් ලෙස ඝාතනයන් කල සමයකි. කැරළිකරුවන්  මහජන දේපළ ගිනි තබා විනාශ කළහ​. මේ භීෂන සමය ශ්‍රී ලංකාව තුල සාමූහික ව්‍යසනයක් ඇති කල අතර එහි මනෝවිද්‍යාත්මක බලපෑම අද දක්වා සමාජ පුරා පවතියි.

ශ්‍රී ලාංකික සමාජය සහ එහි ජනතාව ව්‍යසන වලින් පාඩම් ඉගන නොගත් කොටසකි. මූලික හේතුව නම් සත්‍යට ඔවුන් තුල තිබෙන බිය සහ නොකැමැත්තය​.  සත්‍ය සඟවන සහ බොරුව ව්‍යාජය හුවා දක්වන සමාජයක් කිසි දිනෙක ව්‍යසන සහ ක්‍ෂිතිමය අත්දැකීම් වලින් සුවපත් වන්නේ නැත​. 

සමහරක් විට මිනිසුන් උදාර අරමුණු වෙනුවෙන් ඝාතන විනාශ කරති. උදාහරණයක් ලෙස පොල්පොට් මිනිසුන්ව කුඹුරු වලට යවා පොලිතින් උර හිසට දමා ඝාතනය කලේ උදාර සමාජවාදී පරමාර්ථ වෙනුවෙනි. ස්ටාලින් මිලියන ගනනක් ගුලාග් ශ්‍රම කඳවුරු වලදී මරා දමන්නේ උදාර පරමාර්ථ වෙනුවෙනි. පරමාර්ථය උදාර වූ පමනින් ක්‍රියාව සාධාරණීකරනය වන්නේ නැත​. එසේම ඝාතකයන් සහ ඝාතන රොමෑන්තීකරනය කිරීමෙන් සමාජයට යහපතක් වන්නේ නැත. 

ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ තම අතීත අත්දැකීම් සඳහන් කිරීමේදී වඩාත් සත්‍යවාදී වූයේ නම් ඔහුට සමාජයට යම් මෙහෙයක් කිරීමට හැකි බව මාගේ අදහසයි. ඔහු සමහර අතීත කරුණු ලිවීමේදී සත්‍ය සඟවන බව 88-89 කාලයේ එලියකන්ද වධ කඳවුරේ රැඳවියෙකු වූ රෝහිත මුණසිංහ ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ ගේ මුහුනු පොතේ සඳහන් කොට තිබූ අතර  ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ ඊට පිලිතුරක් දුන්නේ නැත​. එසේම මා විසින් ඔවුන් ගේ 88-89 කාලයේ කරන ලද යම් යම් කාර්‍යභාරයන් විමසන විට  ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ කරන ලද්දේ මාගේ කොමෙන්ට් කපා දැමීමය​. උදාර අරමුණක් වෙනුවෙන් ජීවිතය පරදුවට තබා ක්‍රියා කල කැරලිකරුවෙක් කොමෙන්ට් එකකට බිය වීම ප්‍රශ්නාර්ථයකි. 

1988 / 89 යනු අතීතයට එක්වූ සුවපත් නොවූ මතකයකි. අප අතීතයට බිය යුතු සහ අතීතය සඟවන මානසිකත්වයට නොයා යුතුය​.  ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ දක්‍ෂ ලේඛකයෙකි. ඔහු අතීත අත්දැකීම් ලේඛනගත කිරීම ඉතා වැදගත් ක්‍රියාවකි. යම් කාලයක සමාජ විද්‍යාඥයන්ට මනෝ විද්‍යාඥයන්ට ශ්‍රී ලාංකික සමාජය පිලිබඳ අධ්‍යනය කිරීම සඳහා ඉන් අවකාශ ලැබේ. නමුත්   ගාමිණී මුතුකුමාරණ වඩාත් සත්‍යවාදී සහ විවෘත වන්නේ නම් ඔහුට සමාජය සුවපත් කිරීම සඳහා මෙහෙයක් කල හැක​. නමුත් අතීතය සැඟවීම හෝ සංස්කරණය කිරීම මගින් සමාජයක් හීල් වන්නේ නැත​. සිදු වන්නේ අතීත ව්‍යසනයන් යලි අනාගතයේ පුනරුක්තියට ලක් වීමය 

Find Us On Facebook